Wednesday, February 15, 2006

See ya, Sharia!

Mantaining balances in our multi-cultural society is not always easy. But in order for government and society to function smoothly there can be no legal exceptions that provide one group with certain privileges and deprive another of the same privileges. And so the prospect of allowing Sharia Law in Ontario to settle family law matters has been denied- thank god (or Allah, Mohammed or Buddha for that matter). Unfortunately, the Jewish community, who have used binding arbitration for years as a peaceful, judicious means of settling family disputes, will no longer to be able to do so.

While we still have a way to go towards equality of religion, ethnicity and culture in our society (a red herring that comes to mind is the existence of Catholic schools) this decision should be lauded, not only by women's and children's rights advocates, but by those who value the laws of our land. The institution of law is the most accurate reflection of what makes a society tick. Allowing the intrusion of such intolerant views into our legal system would have indeed been contrary to what the vast majority of Canadians value. It would have weakened the very fabric of our justice system. It would have been a grave mistake.

4 Comments:

Anonymous Anonymous said...

I agree... with most of it.
You covered all the bases and the comparison to the Catholic school system is excellent (and worthy of another debate at another time).
However, Sharia Law doesn't always subject women to abuse and/or misrepresentation. It can work and has the ability to work successfully. The main concern is about the women who are forced into improprer arbitration - the women who are forced into a deal with which they don't agree with either side.
Unfortunately, this can be prevalent in Muslim societies and, hence, McGuinty did the right thing.
In this case, it's all or nothing.

12:48 PM, February 15, 2006  
Blogger Harding said...

Here here. Catholics are next. Nothing against Catholics (being one, albeit not a good one) - but your schools are a big problem (especially the one I went to, where the nuns did not wear underwear).

No government sponsored religious education. Public education for all!

Have you ever seen the underside of a nun? It's like turning Donald Duck upside down...

9:19 PM, February 15, 2006  
Blogger K-Dough said...

It never made sense to me growing up that kids in my neghbourhood went to two types of schools (AND ethnic cultural school on the weekends!).

While I hope that we as Canadians hold the idea of religious equality to be valuable, we also have a responsiblity to fix the mess our predecesors left us in terms of Catholic/public education.

7:09 AM, February 16, 2006  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

You have an outstanding good and well structured site. I enjoyed browsing through it Valium metadon street crimes class ultram viagra vioxx xenical Effect+vicodin Drug interactions imitrex and ciprofloxacin Celebrex cheapest lawyer price vioxx 20 drug effects prescription ultram Memory card writer Xenical weight loss diet

1:19 AM, February 05, 2007  

Post a Comment

<< Home